The Spanish r
Two Spanish r sounds – and why the German r sounds different.
In Spanish, two different r sounds can even distinguish two different words. On top of that, there is a clear difference from the common German pronunciation of r. Both can be followed in authentic corpus recordings.
Listening comparison: pero – perro
How do the two r sounds differ?
Reference speaker
Spain · W90
Reference speaker
Chile · W90
Solution: What can be heard? Hide solution
In both recordings, the tip of the tongue taps once, briefly, in pero [ˈpeɾo] and several times in quick succession in perro [ˈpero]. That difference is enough to turn “but” into “dog”.
Two r sounds – and the spelling helps
Both Spanish r sounds are made at the front of the mouth, with the tip of the tongue at the alveolar ridge. For the tap [ɾ], the tongue tip strikes the ridge only once, briefly. For the trill [r], it rests loosely at the ridge and is set vibrating by the airstream, so that several rapid contacts occur. In Standard German, by contrast, the r is often produced further back, at the uvula.
Between vowels, the two sounds distinguish words, and the spelling makes this visible: a single ⟨r⟩ stands for [ɾ], ⟨rr⟩ for [r] – pero and perro, caro and carro.
At the beginning of a word there is no such contrast. There, a single written ⟨r⟩ usually stands for the trill, for example in reloj [reˈlox].
Tap and trill – in other words, too
Listening comparison: caro
How does the tapped r sound for the two reference speakers?
Reference speaker
Spain · W85
Reference speaker
Chile · W85
Listening comparison: carro
How does the trilled rr sound for the two reference speakers?
Reference speaker
Spain · W57
Reference speaker
Chile · W57
When the German r is carried over into Spanish
In Standard German, the r is usually produced at the back: as a uvular fricative [ʁ] at the uvula, not with the tip of the tongue. Regionally, however, German also has r sounds produced at the front. Anyone who transfers the back habit may sometimes pronounce an initial r, as in reloj, further back instead of as the trill [r].
Listening comparison: reloj
How does the r at the beginning of the word differ in the two recordings?
Reference speaker
Chile · W2
Learner
L1 German · W2
Reír begins and ends with an r. German-speaking learners may sometimes carry over two habits here: a back r at the beginning of the word and a vocalised one at the end. Here, the focus is on the beginning of the word; the end of the word is treated in more detail on the topic page The r at the End of a Word.
Listening comparison: reír
How does the r at the beginning of the word sound in the two recordings?
Reference speaker
Chile · W76
Learner
L1 German · W76
Not every r sounds the same
Even the recordings of caro and carro show it: two speakers do not realise the same r in exactly the same way. Moreover, the Spanish-speaking world has further regional realisations of the r, which the digital textbook presents with listening examples (in German). Not every deviation from a single reference model is therefore a pronunciation error. For teaching, what matters first is that the tap and the trill are told apart and that the tip of the tongue works at the front, at the alveolar ridge.
Classroom prompts
-
Hear the difference first
Use the word pairs pero / perro and caro / carro to draw attention to the meaning-distinguishing function of the tap and the trill – first listen and let learners describe what differs, then clarify the meanings.
-
Make the place of articulation conscious
Briefly contrast the front Spanish r with the back r common in Standard German, for example with Rose and rosa. For claro, the digital textbook suggests first imagining a d instead of the r and saying it faster and faster until the tip of the tongue taps by itself.
-
Use the spelling as a help
Use the word pairs to show that ⟨r⟩ and ⟨rr⟩ between vowels mark a real difference in sound. Learners’ existing heritage languages can be brought in here.
Further exploration
Further chapters of the digital textbook and a related topic page.
-
Pronunciation in the digital textbook
The r sounds of Spanish and German, regional variants and the exercise with claro (in German). Learn more →
-
Orthography in the digital textbook
The relationship between letters and sounds in Spanish (in German). Learn more →
-
Heritage languages in the digital textbook
Why Turkish, Kurdish or Italian can be an advantage for the trilled r (in German). Learn more →
-
The r at the End of a Word
Why the r at the end of a word sounds different in Spanish than in German – and what German r-vocalisation has to do with it. Go to topic page →