The r at the End of a Word
Why the German r often turns into a vowel while the Spanish r stays consonantal.
In German, the r at the end of a word often hardly sounds like a consonant any more – in Spanish it remains a distinct, audible sound. The first listening comparison shows what that means.
Listening comparison: flor
How does the r at the end of the word sound in the two recordings?
Reference speaker
Spain · W16
Learner
L1 German · W16
Solution: What can be heard? Hide solution
In the reference speaker’s recording, flor ends with a brief tap of the tongue against the alveolar ridge: [ˈfloɾ]. The learner, by contrast, lets the word fade out as a vowel without any audible tongue contact, roughly [ˈfloɐ̯] – just as one knows it from the German r at the end of a word.
When the German r becomes a vowel
In Standard German, this is not a mistake but the normal case: after vowels, /r/ is frequently vocalised. In sehr (“very”), the r after the long vowel is heard only as an off-glide, roughly [zeːɐ̯]. In unstressed endings such as in Vater and Lehrer, the vowel [ɐ] takes its place, the so-called “Vater schwa” (also low schwa): [ˈfaːtɐ], [ˈleːʁɐ]. The two phenomena are related, but not identical in every respect.
The German word sehr thus demonstrates r-vocalisation itself: there is hardly a consonantal r left in it.
Spanish behaves differently. At the end of a word, the r usually remains a consonant, mostly a brief tap [ɾ]: flor [ˈfloɾ]. Regionally and depending on context, the realisation can be weaker, longer or different, but as a rule it remains a consonant. Anyone who transfers the German habit will pronounce flor more like [ˈfloɐ̯].
Listening comparison: lavar
How is the word-final r realised in the two recordings?
Reference speaker
Spain · W9
Learner
L1 German · W9
When a consonant follows the r
German r-vocalisation and its possible transfer concern not only the absolute end of a word but often also an r at the end of a syllable – even inside a word. In enfermo, the r stands before the m, in Spanish usually as a brief tap [en.ˈfeɾ.mo]; vocalised, the word would sound roughly like [en.ˈfeɐ̯.mo]. What flor and enfermo have in common is the syllable-final position of the r.
Listening comparison: enfermo
How does the r before m sound in the two recordings?
Reference speaker
Mexico · W50
Learner
L1 German · W50
Especially tricky: r at the beginning and at the end
Reír (“to laugh”) brings both together. In Spanish, the word begins with a trilled r and ends with a tap: [re.ˈiɾ]. German-speaking learners may transfer two habits at once here: a back [ʁ] at the beginning of the word and vocalisation at the end, roughly [ʁe.ˈɪɐ].
Reír also appears on the topic page Soft Spanish, hard German, seen from another angle – the glottal stop between the two vowels. Here, only the r matters.
Listening comparison: reír
How do the r at the beginning and the r at the end of the word sound in the two recordings?
Reference speaker
Chile · W76
Learner
L1 German · W76
Classroom prompts
-
Discover your own German
Say familiar words such as sehr, Vater and Lehrer and draw attention to the r-vocalisation that is regular in German. Where can a consonantal r still be heard at the end – and where not?
-
Listen to Spanish word endings consciously
Use the listening examples flor and lavar as well as further simple words such as tirar to hear and try out the consonantal word-final r, with a brief tongue contact at the alveolar ridge and no additional vowel at the end.
-
From word ending to syllable
Use enfermo to carry the observation over to the syllable-final position. Reír additionally shows that different German r habits – at the beginning and at the end of a word – can work together in a single word.
Further exploration
Related pages on the r in Spanish and German.
-
Pronunciation in the digital textbook
The r sounds of Spanish and German, German r-vocalisation and the example reír (in German). Learn more →
-
The Spanish r
The single and the multiple tap r – and the contrast caro – carro. Go to topic page →
-
Soft Spanish, hard German
Another perspective on reír and on the sound contrast between German and Spanish. Go to topic page →